Karen Read is currently facing a serious legal charge of second-degree murder related to the tragic incident involving her boyfriend, John O’Keefe, who served as a dedicated Boston police officer.
The incident took place in January 2022.
However, her defense team strongly asserts her innocence, alleging a potential case of framing and a suspected coverup involving another police officer and his sister-in-law.
The case has witnessed a series of intriguing developments, unveiling fresh evidence and allegations during courtroom proceedings.
Now, let’s delve into our current understanding of the situation.
The Night of the Death
On January 29, 2022, James O’Keefe was discovered incapacitated and experiencing bleeding near a residence in Canton, Massachusetts, amidst a severe blizzard.
Tragically, he was later declared deceased upon arrival at the hospital.
The primary factor behind his passing was identified as blunt force trauma affecting the head and torso.
The home was owned by Brian Albert, a Boston police officer and a close associate of O’Keefe.
Albert graciously hosted O’Keefe and Read, who had been in a romantic relationship for approximately one year, for an evening of socializing and dining at his residence.
As per Albert’s account, he retired for the night at approximately 11 p.m., leaving O’Keefe and Read in the living room area.
According to Read’s statement to the police, she disagreed with O’Keefe, which resulted in him leaving the house around midnight.
She stated that she pursued him in her SUV, attempting to persuade him to reenter the vehicle.
Despite her efforts, he declined and proceeded on foot.
Subsequently, she lost sight of him and began searching for him while driving.
Eventually, upon returning to Albert’s house, she discovered O’Keefe lying on the ground.
She promptly called 911 for assistance and attempted to perform CPR on him.
The Case Against Read
The police arrested Read on February 1, 2022, and charged her with second-degree murder.
They alleged that she intentionally hit O’Keefe with her SUV and dragged him for about 100 feet before leaving him to die in the snow
The prosecution’s case is based on several pieces of evidence, including:
- Surveillance video from a nearby gas station that shows Read’s SUV driving erratically and making a U-turn shortly before O’Keefe was found.
- Blood and tissue samples from Read’s SUV that matched O’Keefe’s DNA.
- Tire tracks and drag marks on the snow matched Read’s SUV.
- Cellphone data that showed Read searched for “how long does it take for someone to freeze to death” on the night of O’Keefe’s death.
- Witness statements from neighbors who heard a loud thud and a woman screaming around the time of O’Keefe’s death.
- Autopsy results that showed O’Keefe had injuries consistent with being hit by a vehicle.
The Case for Read
Read pleaded not guilty and maintained her innocence.
Her defense team argued that she was framed and that there is a conspiracy involving Albert and his sister-in-law, Jennifer McCabe.
The defense’s case is based on several pieces of evidence, including:
- A dog bite expert testified that O’Keefe had injuries on his right arm that looked like they were caused by an animal attack, not by a vehicle.
- A forensic pathologist testified that O’Keefe had injuries on his head and neck that suggested he was strangled or suffocated, not hit by a vehicle.
- A cellphone expert testified that Read’s phone was hacked and that the search for “how long does it take for someone to freeze to death” was made after she was arrested, not on the night of O’Keefe’s death.
- A private investigator testified that he found blood stains inside Albert’s house that matched O’Keefe’s DNA.
- A witness who testified that he saw Albert and McCabe carrying a large object wrapped in a tarp from Albert’s house to his garage on the night of O’Keefe’s death.
The defense also raised questions about Albert’s motive, suggesting that he had a romantic interest in Read and that he was jealous of O’Keefe. They also claimed that Albert and McCabe had connections to organized crime and that they were involved in illegal activities.
The Latest Developments
The case is still ongoing and has been delayed several times due to the COVID-19 pandemic and other issues.
The latest hearing was held on May 24, 2023, where the judge granted Read’s lawyers access to records involving Albert’s dog, which they believe could prove their theory that O’Keefe was killed inside Albert’s house.
The judge also scheduled another hearing for June 1, 2023, where she will decide whether to allow the defense to call Albert and McCabe as witnesses.
The defense has subpoenaed them, but their lawyers have filed motions to quash the subpoenas, arguing that they are vexatious and harassing.
The trial date has not been set yet, but it is expected to be a high-profile and contentious one, with both sides presenting conflicting evidence and theories.
The outcome could have serious implications for the integrity of the Boston police department and the justice system.
Also, read;
